Motorcycle Accidents and No-Fault in New York and New Jersey
Motorcycle Accidents and No-Fault in New York and New Jersey
In New York, motorcyclists and their passengers are not covered by no-fault insurance, so medical bills after a motorcycle accident are paid through health insurance, optional medical payments coverage, or a liability claim against the at-fault driver. New Jersey’s PIP likewise does not cover motorcycles. Riders who assumed their own policy would pay the emergency room bill learn otherwise when the first denial arrives, and insurance adjusters know it. Attorney Ara Naljian, licensed in New York and New Jersey, explains the rule in each state, what it means for medical bills and lost wages, the one advantage riders have in New York, and where the money actually comes from.
In short
- New York: Motorcycles are not “motor vehicles” under the no-fault law, so riders and passengers get no first-party no-fault benefits from any policy, including the car driver’s.
- New Jersey: PIP applies to “automobiles,” and motorcycles are excluded, so riders get no PIP medical benefits.
- Medical bills: Health insurance, optional medical payments coverage on the motorcycle policy, and ultimately the at-fault driver’s liability insurer are potential payment sources.
- New York upside: Because riders are outside the no-fault system, the serious injury threshold generally does not apply to a motorcyclist’s claim against a driver.
- UM/UIM coverage: Uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage on the motorcycle policy can protect a rider when the driver has no insurance or too little.
The rule most riders learn after the crash
Both New York and New Jersey are no-fault states for car accidents: after a crash, a car occupant’s own insurer pays medical bills and a portion of lost wages regardless of fault, quickly and without a lawsuit. Riders reasonably assume the same system applies to them. It does not. Both states wrote motorcycles out of the no-fault system, on the theory that the benefits would be too expensive to require for a vehicle whose occupants are so exposed.
The consequence is that a motorcyclist hit by a car on the FDR Drive or the Palisades Interstate Parkway has no automatic source of payment for the ambulance, the surgery, or the weeks out of work. The claim exists; it simply runs on different rails, and the first weeks are spent mapping which policies will pay.
New York: motorcyclists are excluded from no-fault benefits
New York’s no-fault law (Insurance Law Article 51) requires every “motor vehicle” policy to provide first-party benefits, basic economic loss up to $50,000, to the vehicle’s occupants and to pedestrians it strikes.
The statute’s definition of motor vehicle for this purpose expressly excludes motorcycles (Insurance Law 5102(f)). Two results follow. A motorcycle policy is not required to carry no-fault coverage for its own rider or passenger, and none do.
And the car driver’s no-fault coverage, which would pay a pedestrian the car struck, does not pay a motorcyclist or a motorcycle passenger the car struck, because the statute’s first-party benefit provision (Insurance Law 5103) excludes occupants of a motorcycle. A rider therefore has no no-fault claim against anyone.
The exclusion runs one way. A pedestrian struck by a motorcycle is entitled to no-fault benefits from the motorcycle’s insurer, which is why New York motorcycle policies carry a limited no-fault component for non-occupants.
New Jersey: PIP doesn't apply to motorcycles either
New Jersey’s Automobile Reparation Reform Act requires personal injury protection on every “automobile,” and the statutory definition of automobile (N.J.S.A. 39:6A-2) does not include motorcycles.
A motorcycle policy in New Jersey carries liability coverage and, at the rider’s option, uninsured/underinsured motorist and medical payments coverage, but no PIP.
A rider injured by a car cannot claim PIP from their own motorcycle policy, from their own car policy (PIP under an auto policy covers injuries arising from an automobile, and the rider was on a motorcycle), or from the car driver’s policy.
As in New York, the medical bills go to health insurance, to optional med-pay if purchased, and to the liability claim.
One New Jersey wrinkle should be checked in every case: whether the rider, or a resident family member, holds an automobile policy with the “limitation on lawsuit” option, because the verbal threshold’s application to a motorcyclist’s claim depends on the rider’s own policy situation and should be confirmed by an attorney rather than assumed either way.
What that means in practice for medical bills and lost wages
For a car occupant, the emergency room bills the no-fault carrier and the injured person never sees an invoice. For a rider, the emergency room bills the rider.
Providers will ask for auto insurance information, be told there is no no-fault, and bill health insurance if the rider has it or the rider directly if not.
Physical therapy, orthopedic follow-up, and imaging require pre-authorization from the health plan, which may be slower and narrower than what a no-fault carrier would have approved.
Lost wages, which no-fault would have paid at 80 percent up to a monthly cap in New York, are not paid by anyone until the liability claim resolves, unless the rider carries disability coverage through work.
Adjusters for the at-fault driver’s insurer understand this gap. A rider with mounting bills, no wage replacement, and a liability carrier that has not admitted fault is under pressure to accept an early, low settlement, and the first offer is often timed to that pressure.
In our practice, the coverage map is built in the first week precisely so that the client is not negotiating from a hospital bill.
The upside: the serious injury threshold generally does not apply to riders in NY
New York’s no-fault trade-off has two halves: guaranteed benefits, and a limit on lawsuits. Because a motorcyclist is outside the benefits half, the motorcyclist is generally outside the limits half as well.
The serious injury threshold (Insurance Law 5104(a)) bars a “covered person” from recovering non-economic loss from another covered person unless the injury meets the statutory definition of serious injury.
A motorcycle operator or passenger injured by a car is generally not a covered person under the no-fault law with respect to that accident, so the threshold generally does not apply to the rider’s claim against the driver: pain and suffering can be pursued for any injury caused by the driver’s negligence, without proving a fracture, a permanent limitation, or 90 days of disability.
That is a meaningful advantage, and it is stated here with a deliberate “generally,” because the analysis depends on the specific facts (who was struck by what, and under which policies) and because the rule is applied by courts to the circumstances of each case.
Have an attorney confirm it for your accident before relying on it.
Riders should also know that the threshold’s absence does not remove comparative fault: New York reduces the recovery by the rider’s share of fault, and the rider-bias arguments defendants make are the subject of our companion guide on helmets, lane filtering, and comparative fault.
Who pays: the at-fault driver, your health insurance, med-pay, and UM
With no no-fault, the rider’s compensation comes from a stack of sources, and the order matters.
Liability claim against the driver
The primary source of recovery is the at-fault driver’s liability insurance, which pays medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering once fault and damages are established, usually months after the crash and only at settlement or verdict.
Minimum limits are low in both states, so the value of the claim is often capped by the driver’s policy unless additional coverage is found; see our guide to what decides case value.
Because nothing is paid until the end, the sources below carry the rider in the meantime.
Health insurance and liens
Health insurance is the rider’s main interim source for medical bills, and most plans cover motorcycle injuries; a few employer plans carry source-of-injury exclusions, so the plan document should be checked immediately.
When the liability claim resolves, the health plan, Medicare, or Medicaid may assert a lien or reimbursement claim against the recovery for what it paid.
The rules differ by plan type and by state (New York limits the reimbursement rights of many private health insurers by statute; self-funded employer plans and government programs have stronger rights), and the lien is negotiated before the settlement is distributed.
Optional medical payments coverage
Both states allow riders to buy medical payments coverage on the motorcycle policy: a no-fault-like benefit that pays medical bills for the rider and passenger regardless of fault, up to a chosen limit, often a few thousand dollars.
It is inexpensive, rarely purchased, and the first thing to look for on the declarations page after a crash.
If you are reading this before an accident rather than after one, add it at your next renewal.
Uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage on your motorcycle policy
When the driver who hit you fled, had no insurance, or carried the minimum, your own motorcycle policy’s uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage (SUM in New York, UM/UIM in New Jersey) stands in for the driver’s liability coverage, up to the limit you bought.
Because riders are the most exposed road users and the most likely to be seriously hurt by a minimally insured driver, UM/UIM limits on a motorcycle policy should match or exceed the liability limits; the premium difference is small.
Hit-and-run claims under this coverage require a prompt police report and notice to your insurer; our guide to hit-and-run and uninsured driver claims covers the deadlines.
Passengers
A motorcycle passenger is in the same position as the rider with respect to no-fault and PIP: excluded in both states, and in New York generally outside the serious injury threshold as well.
The passenger’s sources of recovery are the same stack, with one addition: the passenger may have a liability claim against the motorcycle operator if the operator’s negligence contributed to the crash, and that claim is paid by the motorcycle policy’s liability coverage.
A passenger who was a resident relative of the operator, or who has their own auto policy, may also have UM/UIM coverage available through those policies.
The contrast with pedestrians is sharp: a pedestrian struck by a car in either state receives no-fault or PIP benefits from the striking vehicle’s insurer or their own household policy; see how pedestrians’ medical bills get paid.
PERSONAL INJURY ATTORNEY
Get the Legal Help You Deserve
-
New York No-Fault Insurance and the Serious Injury Threshold: 2026 Update -
What to Do After a Car Accident in New York -
New York Notice of Claim Deadlines for Injuries Involving Municipalities -
How Long Do You Have to File a Personal Injury Lawsuit in New York? -
How Long Do You Have to File a Personal Injury Lawsuit in New Jersey?
Injured in a Motorcycle Accident? Your Medical Bills Shouldn't Define Your Future.
- Free Consultation
- No Win, No Fee
- We Fight for You