New York’s 2026 Motor Vehicle Reforms: What Changed for Injured Drivers (Effective May 26, 2026)

The most significant change to New York car accident law in decades took effect with the state budget on May 26, 2026. Four provisions matter to injured people, and the date your lawsuit is filed determines which rules apply.

What Did New York’s 2026 Motor Vehicle Reform Change?

Part EE of Chapter 58 of the Laws of 2026, effective May 26, 2026, made four changes to New York motor vehicle injury claims: it deleted the 90/180-day “serious injury” category from Insurance Law § 5102(d); it bars recovery when the injured person’s fault exceeds the defendants’ (CPLR § 1411(b)); it requires juries to decide fault before serious injury (§ 5104(a)); and it caps pain-and-suffering at $100,000 for certain at-fault uninsured, impaired or felony drivers (§ 5104(d)). The changes apply to actions commenced on or after May 26, 2026.

Key Facts at a Glance

  • The trigger is the date the lawsuit is filed, not the date of the crash.

  • No-fault benefits (up to $50,000 in basic economic loss) did not change.

  • Joint and several liability for motor vehicle defendants was proposed for repeal but was not changed.

  • Non-motor-vehicle negligence cases, including construction, premises and medical negligence, are unaffected; pure comparative fault still applies to them.

  • Several provisions have open interpretive questions that New York appellate courts have not yet decided.

Table of Contents

  1. How the Reform Came About

  2. Change 1: The 90/180-Day Serious Injury Category Is Gone

  3. Change 2: The “Mostly at Fault” Bar Under CPLR § 1411(b)

  4. Change 3: Fault Is Decided Before Serious Injury

  5. Change 4: The $100,000 Cap for Certain At-Fault Drivers

  6. What the Legislature Did Not Change

  7. Which Cases the New Rules Apply To

  8. Before-and-After Comparison Table

  9. What Injured Drivers Should Do Differently Now

  10. Open Questions the Courts Will Have to Answer

  11. How ARAVANA LAW Is Handling Post-Reform Claims

  12. Frequently Asked Questions

1. How the Reform Came About

Governor Hochul announced the proposals in her January 13, 2026 State of the State address as part of a plan to lower auto insurance premiums. Her office described average premiums as just over $4,000 a year in New York, roughly $1,500 above the national average. The package was negotiated into the FY2027 state budget.

Chapter 58 of the Laws of 2026 (S9008-C/A10008-C) was signed on May 26, 2026, and the Governor announced the auto insurance provisions the following day. The tort changes sit in Part EE of that chapter and amend Insurance Law §§ 5102 and 5104 and CPLR § 1411.

The reform was contested. The New York State Trial Lawyers Association objected that it was pushed through the budget process rather than ordinary legislation and that it was backed by an unusually expensive insurer and rideshare lobbying campaign. Street-safety advocates argued that people with concussions and soft-tissue injuries could be left with only no-fault benefits, whose $50,000 limit has not changed since the 1970s.

Insurers and defense firms welcomed the changes. The Department of Financial Services has since ordered every auto insurer to quantify the expected claims savings in its rate filings and has proposed prior approval for any future rate increase.

Whether and when premiums actually fall is a separate question from how the law now treats an injured driver. That is the focus of this article.

2. Change 1: The 90/180-Day Serious Injury Category Is Gone

What the Category Was

Under New York’s no-fault system, a person injured in a car accident generally cannot sue another covered person for pain and suffering unless they prove a “serious injury” as defined in Insurance Law § 5102(d).

Before the reform, the definition contained nine categories. The ninth covered a medically determined injury or impairment of a non-permanent nature that prevented the injured person from performing substantially all of their usual and customary daily activities for at least 90 of the 180 days immediately after the accident.

In practice, this category applied to people whose injuries eventually healed but who lost months of normal life.

For example:

  • A worker who was unable to work for four months because of a back injury that eventually resolved.

  • A student who could not attend school for a semester after suffering a concussion.

  • A parent who could not lift a child or drive during the recovery period.

What Changed?

Part EE deleted that category.

The definition now has eight categories:

  1. Death.

  2. Dismemberment.

  3. Significant disfigurement.

  4. A fracture.

  5. Loss of a fetus.

  6. Permanent loss of use of a body organ, member, function or system.

  7. Permanent consequential limitation of use of a body organ or member.

  8. Significant limitation of use of a body function or system.

The full list, side by side with New Jersey’s verbal threshold, is discussed in our article on the New Jersey verbal threshold and the New York serious injury threshold.

What It Means for Injured Drivers

A temporary but disabling injury no longer qualifies on its own under the deleted 90/180-day category.

To recover pain and suffering, the same injury must now be documented as a significant limitation of use or a permanent consequential limitation, which requires objective medical evidence.

Examples of relevant documentation include:

  • Imaging correlated with the patient’s complaints.

  • Quantified range-of-motion deficits measured against normal.

  • A treating physician’s opinion concerning the duration and significance of the injury.

The practical effect is that early, thorough and well-documented treatment matters more than ever. Gaps in treatment may be more damaging than before.

3. Change 2: The “Mostly at Fault” Bar Under CPLR § 1411(b)

The Old Rule

New York was a pure comparative negligence state.

Under CPLR § 1411, a plaintiff’s own fault reduced the award but never completely barred recovery. A driver found 70 percent at fault could still recover 30 percent of their damages.

The New Rule

New CPLR § 1411(b) applies only to personal injury actions subject to Insurance Law Article 51, meaning motor vehicle injury cases within the no-fault system.

In those cases, the injured person’s culpable conduct now bars recovery entirely if it is greater than the culpable conduct of the person sued, or greater than the combined culpable conduct of all the persons sued.

At 50 percent fault, you can still recover half. At 51 percent fault, you recover nothing from the other driver under the new rule.

Worked Examples

Example 1: You are 30 percent at fault.

The other driver is 70 percent at fault. You recover 70 percent of your damages, as before.

Example 2: Both drivers are 50 percent at fault.

You recover 50 percent. Your fault is not greater than the defendant’s.

Example 3: You are 60 percent at fault.

The other driver is 40 percent at fault. Before May 26, 2026, you would have recovered 40 percent of your damages. In an action filed on or after that date, you recover nothing from the other driver. Your no-fault benefits are unaffected.

Example 4: There are multiple defendants.

You are 40 percent at fault. Driver A is 35 percent at fault, and Driver B is 25 percent at fault.

Your fault is greater than each defendant’s individually but less than their combined 60 percent. The statute is written in the alternative, and commentators on both sides have identified this as an unresolved question. See Section 10.

What It Means for Injured Drivers

Fault evidence is now case-dispositive, not merely a factor that reduces damages.

Scene photographs, police reports, vehicle event data, dash-camera footage, surveillance video and witness statements can determine whether there is a case at all.

Most commercial video is overwritten within days to weeks. Preservation therefore needs to happen in the first week.

4. Change 3: Fault Is Decided Before Serious Injury

Amended Insurance Law § 5104(a) now directs the trier of fact to determine which party or parties were at fault before deciding whether the injury is a serious injury. It also provides that liability for non-economic loss is not established unless a serious injury is found.

Two consequences follow.

First, at trial, the jury answers the fault question first. If the plaintiff is more than 50 percent at fault, the trial ends there without reaching injury or damages.

Second, by tying liability to both a fault finding and a serious injury finding, the amendment affects when prejudgment interest begins to run. This is an issue on which the appellate departments had previously disagreed.

Defense commentators also expect the change to reshape motion practice.

Since the Court of Appeals’ 2018 decision in Rodriguez v. City of New York, a plaintiff seeking partial summary judgment on liability has not had to disprove their own comparative fault because fault previously reduced damages rather than eliminating the claim.

Now that fault can defeat an Article 51 claim outright, defendants will argue that comparative fault belongs in the liability motion.

5. Change 4: The $100,000 Cap for Certain At-Fault Drivers

New Insurance Law § 5104(d) caps non-economic damages at $100,000 in a serious injury action brought by or on behalf of an injured person who was at fault and who, at the time of the accident, was in one of the following situations:

  1. Operating an uninsured motor vehicle in violation of Vehicle and Traffic Law Article 6, other than during a lapse in coverage of fewer than 30 days.

  2. Operating a vehicle while impaired by alcohol or drugs and later convicted of that offense.

  3. Operating a vehicle in the commission of a felony, or in immediate flight from one, and later convicted.

The cap does not apply where the accident resulted in death, and it does not limit economic damages.

Because it applies only to claimants who were at fault, it operates on people who were partly, but not mostly, responsible. A claimant more than 50 percent at fault recovers nothing in any event under the new fault bar.

The conviction requirement creates a timing problem that both plaintiff and defense lawyers have identified.

A civil case may be ready to settle or go to trial before the criminal case is resolved. A charge that is pleaded down may or may not satisfy the statute.

As a result, motions to stay civil cases pending criminal outcomes may become an issue in litigation.

6. What the Legislature Did Not Change

Several things the Governor proposed in January did not survive, and several things people assume changed did not.

Joint and Several Liability

The proposal to repeal CPLR § 1602(6), the motor vehicle exception to Article 16’s limits on joint liability, was not enacted.

A defendant found even a small percentage at fault can still be held liable for the entire non-economic award if a co-defendant is uninsured or insolvent.

For injured people, this matters because the well-insured defendant remains fully responsible under the applicable rule.

No-Fault Benefits

Basic economic loss under Insurance Law § 5102(a) remains up to $50,000 per person.

This includes lost earnings of up to $2,000 a month for up to three years, payable regardless of fault.

Your no-fault application deadlines did not change.

Non-Motor-Vehicle Cases

Premises liability, construction claims (including Labor Law § 240), product liability and medical negligence claims remain under pure comparative fault.

The Eight Remaining Serious Injury Categories

The eight remaining serious injury categories were not redefined.

The evidentiary standards from Toure v. Avis and Perl v. Meher still govern.

Wrongful Death

The $100,000 cap does not apply to death cases.

7. Which Cases the New Rules Apply To

According to the Department of Financial Services’ Insurance Circular Letter No. 3 (2026), the reform applies to actions commenced on or after May 26, 2026.

The trigger is the filing of the lawsuit, not the date of the accident.

That has two important consequences.

A crash in 2024 that was sued on in April 2026 is governed by the old law. The same crash sued on in July 2026 is governed by the new law.

A claimant whose accident happened years before the reform but who had not yet filed is now subject to rules that did not exist when they were injured.

Whether a substantive bar to recovery can be applied to conduct that predates it is a due-process question that New York’s appellate courts have not yet answered.

Some early commentary gave May 27 as the effective date. That is the effective date of the separate staged-accident fraud provisions in Chapter 55. For the tort changes, the regulator’s date is May 26.

If you have a claim involving an accident before the reform, the filing-date issue and potential retroactivity questions deserve careful legal review.

8. Before-and-After Comparison Table

IssueActions commenced before May 26, 2026Actions commenced on or after May 26, 2026
Serious injury categoriesNine, including the 90/180-day categoryEight; 90/180-day category deleted
Effect of plaintiff’s own faultReduces award proportionally at any percentageBars recovery if greater than defendants’ fault; otherwise reduces proportionally
Order of decision at trialNo statutory sequenceFault first, then serious injury, then damages
Prejudgment interest on non-economic lossAppellate departments splitLiability requires fault plus serious injury finding
Pain and suffering for at-fault uninsured, convicted impaired or convicted felony driversNo capCapped at $100,000, except in death cases
Joint and several liability (motor vehicle)Full, under CPLR § 1602(6)Unchanged
No-fault basic economic loss$50,000Unchanged
Non-motor-vehicle negligence claimsPure comparative faultUnchanged

Table caption: New York motor vehicle injury claims before and after Part EE of Chapter 58 of the Laws of 2026. General information as of November 2026; not legal advice.

9. What Injured Drivers Should Do Differently Now

The 2026 reforms make evidence preservation and medical documentation particularly important in New York motor vehicle injury claims.

Here are six practical steps injured drivers should consider:

1. Treat fault evidence as urgent.

Photograph the accident scene and vehicles, obtain the police report, identify nearby cameras, and preserve dash-camera and vehicle data in the first week. Under the new bar, a few percentage points of fault can determine the entire case.

2. Do not give the other driver’s insurer a recorded statement.

Adjusters now have a direct incentive to build a mostly-at-fault narrative from your own words. Consider obtaining legal advice before providing a recorded statement.

3. Get evaluated the same day and follow through with treatment.

With the 90/180-day category gone, the limitation-of-use categories require objective findings and a consistent treatment record.

4. Keep your own insurance current.

An uninsured driver who is partly at fault faces the $100,000 cap even with a serious injury. A lapse of 30 days or more removes the statutory short-lapse exception.

5. If your accident happened before May 26, 2026 and you have not filed, get advice now.

The three-year limitations period has not changed, but the rules that apply to your case depend on your filing date. Whether the new rules can constitutionally reach a pre-reform accident remains unsettled.

6. If you were a pedestrian or cyclist, confirm whether your claim is an Article 51 action.

The fault bar applies only to actions within the no-fault framework. Borderline cases will require legal analysis.

10. Open Questions the Courts Will Have to Answer

No appellate court had ruled on the new provisions at the time of writing.

Practitioners on both sides have identified at least six questions:

Multiple Defendants

Whether a claimant’s fault is compared with each defendant separately, with all defendants combined, or with either, in multi-vehicle crashes.

Retroactivity

Whether applying the fault bar to pre-reform accidents in post-reform lawsuits survives a due-process challenge.

Procedure or Substance

Whether fault-first sequencing is procedural, and therefore applies to pending cases at trial, or substantive.

Summary Judgment

How early threshold motions and the Rodriguez line of cases fit with a statute that tells the trier of fact to decide fault first.

The Conviction Trigger

What happens when the civil case moves faster than the criminal case or the criminal charge is reduced.

“Culpable Conduct”

How broadly the term will be interpreted when applying the new recovery bar.

Injured people and their lawyers should plead and preserve both readings of each question until the Appellate Division, and eventually the Court of Appeals, settles them.

11. How ARAVANA LAW Is Handling Post-Reform Claims

Since May 26, 2026, the firm has adjusted how New York car accident cases are built from the first call.

Fault evidence is gathered immediately. Preservation letters go out in the first week to businesses, transit operators and rideshare companies for video and data.

Medical documentation is planned around the surviving serious injury categories from the first visit, not reconstructed later.

For clients whose accidents predate the reform, filing timing and the retroactivity question are discussed at the initial consultation.

And because joint and several liability survived, the firm continues to pursue every responsible defendant, including the well-insured one with a small share of fault.

Ara Naljian handles each case personally from consultation to resolution, in New York and New Jersey.

If you were injured in a New York crash, before or after May 26, 2026, learn more about the firm’s motor vehicle accident practice or contact us for a free case review.

Legal Disclaimer

This article provides general information about New York law as of its last reviewed date. The 2026 reform is new and several provisions are untested in the appellate courts; the analysis may change. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Consult a licensed attorney about your situation.

Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Injured in a New York Car Accident? The Right Legal Guidance Matters.

New York’s motor vehicle laws have changed. Whether your accident happened before or after May 26, 2026, understanding the applicable rules can make an important difference when evaluating your legal options. Speak with ARAVANA LAW about your situation and get a clearer understanding of the next steps.

Four things changed, effective May 26, 2026. The 90/180-day serious injury category was removed from Insurance Law § 5102(d); a new CPLR § 1411(b) bars recovery when the injured person is more at fault than the defendants; § 5104(a) now requires juries to decide fault before serious injury; and § 5104(d) caps pain-and-suffering at $100,000 for certain at-fault uninsured, impaired or felony drivers. No-fault benefits did not change.

Not for lawsuits filed on or after May 26, 2026. The category that allowed a temporary injury to qualify as serious if it prevented someone from performing their usual activities for 90 of the first 180 days was deleted by the 2026 budget. Eight categories remain, including significant limitation of use and permanent consequential limitation, which require objective medical evidence.

Not for an action filed on or after May 26, 2026. Under CPLR § 1411(b), a motor vehicle injury claimant whose fault is greater than the defendants’ recovers nothing from them. At 50 percent fault, you can still recover half of your damages. Your own no-fault benefits are paid regardless of fault. Before the reform, New York allowed recovery at any level of fault.

According to the Department of Financial Services, the amendments apply to actions commenced on or after May 26, 2026, regardless of when the accident happened. A pre-reform accident sued on after that date is governed by the new rules. Whether that can constitutionally be applied to older accidents is an open question that the appellate courts have not decided. If your accident predates the reform and you have not filed, get advice promptly.

New Insurance Law § 5104(d) limits pain-and-suffering damages to $100,000 for an injured person who was at fault and was driving uninsured (other than during a lapse under 30 days), driving impaired and later convicted, or driving in the commission of a felony and later convicted. It does not apply in death cases and does not limit economic damages such as medical bills and lost wages.

Scroll to Top