What Is the Scaffold Law? New York Labor Law 240(1) in Plain English
What Is New York’s Scaffold Law?
New York Labor Law § 240(1), known as the Scaffold Law, requires owners, contractors and their agents to furnish and properly place safety devices — scaffolds, ladders, hoists, slings, braces, ropes and similar equipment — to give proper protection to workers on construction, demolition, repair, alteration, painting, cleaning and pointing work. When a worker is injured by a gravity-related risk because that protection was not provided, the owner and contractor are liable regardless of whether they were personally careless, and the worker’s own negligence does not reduce the recovery. The worker must still show a violation of the statute that caused the injury; a fall by itself is not enough.
Key Facts at a Glance
Your own carelessness does not reduce a § 240(1) recovery. This is the only New York injury claim where that is true.
Liability does not depend on the owner or contractor having supervised or controlled the work.
It is not limited to scaffolds, and you do not have to fall. Falling objects and hoisting injuries count.
There is no minimum height, but the elevation difference must be physically significant.
A fall alone proves nothing. You must show the protection was inadequate and that this caused the injury.
One defense can defeat the entire claim: that your own conduct was the sole proximate cause.
You can bring this claim while collecting workers’ compensation, because it is against the owner and general contractor, not your employer.
Table of Contents
What the Statute Actually Says
The Part That Makes It Powerful: Your Own Carelessness Does Not Count
It Is Not Just Scaffolds, and You Do Not Have to Fall
What You Still Have to Prove
The One Defense That Can End the Case
Who Can Be Sued, and Who Cannot
Sections 240, 241(6) and 200 Compared
Did the 2026 Reforms Change the Scaffold Law?
Workers’ Compensation and the Third-Party Case
What to Do After a Fall from Height
How ARAVANA LAW Handles Scaffold Law Cases
1. What the Statute Actually Says
Labor Law § 240(1) places its duty on “All contractors and owners and their agents,” for work involving the erection, demolition, repairing, altering, painting, cleaning or pointing of a building or structure. It requires that scaffolding, hoists, stays, ladders, slings, hangers, blocks, pulleys, braces, irons, ropes and other devices be “so constructed, placed and operated as to give proper protection to a person so employed.”
Three features of that language do most of the work in practice.
“And their agents.” The duty reaches beyond the titled owner and the general contractor to anyone delegated authority over the work, which is how construction managers and prime contractors are brought in.
“Proper protection.” The standard is not reasonable care and not industry custom. It is whether the protection given was proper for the task. A ladder that meets code but was the wrong tool for the job can still violate the statute.
“So constructed, placed and operated.” A device can be perfectly sound and still violate § 240(1) if it was placed or operated wrongly, which is why unsecured ladders on smooth floors generate so much litigation.
Two further subdivisions get less attention and occasionally matter. Section 240(2) requires a safety rail at least thirty-four inches high on scaffolding or staging more than twenty feet above the ground or floor, along the outside and ends, with an exception for interior scaffolding covering a room’s full floor space. Section 240(3) requires scaffolding built to bear four times the maximum weight placed on it.
2. The Part That Makes It Powerful: Your Own Carelessness Does Not Count
This is the heart of it, and it is unusual enough in American tort law that it is worth stating plainly: if you establish a § 240(1) violation that caused your injury, your own negligence does not reduce what you recover.
In Blake v. Neighborhood Housing Services of New York City, the Court of Appeals confirmed that comparative fault “would reduce a defendant’s responsibility” and is “impermissible under section 240 (1),” and that once a violation and causation are shown, “contributory negligence cannot defeat the plaintiff’s claim.”
Compare that to every other claim available to an injured worker. Under Labor Law § 241(6), the Court of Appeals held in Rizzuto v. L.A. Wenger Contracting Co. that a defendant “may, of course, raise any valid defense to the imposition of vicarious liability under section 241(6), including contributory and comparative negligence.” The same is true of § 200 and of ordinary negligence. In a construction case in New York, comparative fault still reduces recovery on a sliding scale with no bar, because the 2026 motor vehicle reform does not reach these claims — a point explained in the firm’s post on comparative negligence and partial fault.
Liability under § 240(1) is also nondelegable. The owner cannot escape it by pointing out that it hired a competent general contractor and never set foot on the site, and the general contractor cannot escape it by pointing to the subcontractor that actually supplied the ladder. Neither needs to have been negligent at all.
One caution, because this is where competing articles overstate the law. Blake was emphatic that “the words strict or absolute liability do not appear in Labor Law § 240 (1) or any of its predecessors,” and that the labels, which courts use as shorthand, do not mean liability without fault. The statute still requires a violation that proximately caused the injury. Sections 4 and 5 explain what that means in practice.
3. It Is Not Just Scaffolds, and You Do Not Have to Fall
The name misleads people. Two common misconceptions keep workers from calling a lawyer.
You do not have to fall. In Runner v. New York Stock Exchange, a worker was lowering an 800-pound wire reel down a short flight of stairs. Instead of a hoist or pulley, the crew ran a rope around a metal bar and used themselves as counterweights. The reel’s descent pulled the plaintiff forward and crushed his hands against the bar. The reel never struck him and he never fell. The Court of Appeals held the claim good anyway, explaining that the statute protects against “harm directly flowing from the application of the force of gravity to an object or person,” and that the decisive question is whether the injury was the direct consequence of inadequate protection against an elevation-related risk — not whether the worker fell or was struck.
Falling objects count. A tool, a pipe, a bundle of material or a piece of formwork that falls because it was not secured, hoisted or braced as the statute requires is squarely within § 240(1).
There is no minimum height. Courts have applied the statute to falls of a few feet. What matters is whether the elevation differential was physically significant in relation to the force involved, which is why a heavy object falling a short distance can qualify while a person stepping off a low platform may not.
The device list is illustrative, not exhaustive. The statute says “and other devices.” The question is whether an appropriate protective device was provided for the gravity-related risk, not whether the missing item appears on the list.
What the statute does not cover is the ordinary hazard of a construction site that has nothing to do with elevation: tripping over debris on a flat floor, being cut by a tool, inhaling a contaminant. Those are § 241(6), § 200 or negligence claims.
4. What You Still Have to Prove
Two elements, and both are contested in nearly every case.
A violation. The protection provided was not proper for the work: no scaffold where one was needed, a ladder that was unsecured or the wrong height, a hoist that was not used, a railing that was missing, material that was not braced.
Proximate cause. The violation was a contributing cause of the injury.
Blake is explicit that neither the accident nor the violation establishes the claim on its own. “The mere fact that [a plaintiff] fell off the scaffolding surface is insufficient, in and of itself” to show inadequate protection, and “an accident alone does not establish a Labor Law § 240 (1) violation or causation.” Equally, “violation of the statute alone is not enough”; the plaintiff must show the violation contributed to the injury.
This is why the quality of the early investigation drives these cases. If the ladder is photographed, identified and preserved, a claim that it was unsecured is provable. If the ladder is back in the contractor’s van and the only record is a hospital note saying the patient fell at work, the defense will argue the worker simply lost his footing on a perfectly adequate ladder — which, if believed, is the Blake outcome.
Why this claim is worth so much when it is established. Because comparative fault is unavailable and the duty is nondelegable, a plaintiff who proves a violation and causation can often win partial summary judgment on liability before trial, leaving only damages. That changes the settlement posture of a case entirely.
5. The One Defense That Can End the Case
The defense that matters is sole proximate cause. Blake framed the logic precisely: “if a statutory violation is a proximate cause of an injury, the plaintiff cannot be solely to blame for it,” and conversely, “if the plaintiff is solely to blame for the injury, it necessarily means that there has been no statutory violation.”
So the defense is not that the worker was careless, which is irrelevant. It is that there was no violation at all, because adequate protection was there and the worker’s own choice was the whole cause. In Blake itself the ladder was in proper working order and the plaintiff had failed to lock its extension clips, and the claim failed.
Cahill v. Triborough Bridge & Tunnel Authority set out what the defense requires. The worker had climbed a bridge form without a safety line although lines were available and his supervisor had told him weeks earlier to use one. The Court of Appeals held that “where an employer has made available adequate safety devices and an employee has been instructed to use them, the employee may not recover under Labor Law § 240 (1) for injuries caused solely by his violation of those instructions.” The findings that support it are that the worker had adequate devices available, knew they were available and that he was expected to use them, “chose for no good reason not to do so,” and would not have been injured had he not made that choice. The Court added that the passage of weeks since the instruction did not help the worker: he “was not the less recalcitrant because there was a lapse of weeks between the instructions and his disobedience of them.”
Each element is also where the defense usually fails. A device stored in a locked trailer across the site is not readily available. A harness with no anchor point to tie off to is not adequate. A general instruction to work safely is not an instruction to use a particular device. And a worker who used the only equipment he was actually given has not chosen anything “for no good reason.” Defendants invoke sole proximate cause far more often than they establish it.
6. Who Can Be Sued, and Who Cannot
The property owner, whether or not it supervised anything, and generally whether or not it was present.
The general contractor and construction manager, and other contractors delegated authority over the work as statutory agents.
Not your own employer, in most cases. Workers’ compensation is an exclusive remedy against the employer. That is not the obstacle it sounds like, because on most sites the owner and general contractor are different companies from the injured worker’s employer, and they are the § 240(1) defendants. The firm’s post on workers’ compensation versus a third-party lawsuit explains how the two proceed together.
The homeowner exemption. Owners of one- and two-family dwellings are exempt from § 240(1) if they contract for the work but do not direct or control it. A homeowner who hires a roofer and stays out of the way is generally not liable; one who directs the means and methods of the work can lose the exemption. The exemption does not protect the contractor.
Design professionals. Professional engineers, architects and landscape architects are not liable under § 240(1) for failing to provide protection where they do not direct or control the work, unless the activity is planning and design. Other theories of liability against them are unaffected.
Your immigration status is not a defense. Undocumented workers are protected by § 240(1). A defendant raising status is not raising a defense to liability.
7. Sections 240, 241(6) and 200 Compared
Almost every New York construction case pleads all three. They are very different claims.
| Issue | § 240(1) Scaffold Law | § 241(6) Industrial Code | § 200 / Common Law |
|---|---|---|---|
| Covers | Gravity and elevation-related risks | Specific Industrial Code violations | Unsafe site or work conditions generally |
| Must the defendant have controlled the work? | No | No | Yes, authority to control the activity |
| Is the defendant’s own negligence required? | No | No | Yes |
| Is comparative negligence a defense? | No | Yes | Yes |
| What you must prove | Inadequate protection against a gravity risk, plus causation | Violation of a sufficiently specific Code provision, plus causation | Negligence, control, and notice of the condition |
| Partial summary judgment on liability realistic? | Often | Sometimes | Rarely |
Table caption: The three principal New York Labor Law claims available to injured construction workers. General comparison; not legal advice.
A 2026 change worth knowing about. On May 26, 2026 the Court of Appeals decided Mann v. Mezuyon, LLC, tightening what qualifies as a sufficiently specific Industrial Code provision under § 241(6). A driller at a Manhattan excavation site was struck by the swinging rear of an excavator, and his claim rested on 12 NYCRR § 23-4.2(k), which provides that persons shall not be suffered or permitted to work in any area where excavation equipment may strike or endanger them. The Court held the provision too general to support vicarious liability, announcing a two-part test: a provision must both “identify a specific safety concern” and “command a specific action required to address that concern.” Section 23-4.2(k) identified the danger but commanded nothing, so it could not carry the claim. Chief Judge Wilson dissented, joined by two colleagues.
The practical consequence for injured workers is that the § 241(6) fallback got narrower in 2026. A worker whose accident could be framed either as a gravity-related risk or as a general Code violation now has considerably more to gain from the § 240(1) theory, which is a drafting and investigation decision made in the first weeks of a case.
8. Did the 2026 Reforms Change the Scaffold Law?
No. The budget legislation that took effect on May 26, 2026 did not amend Labor Law § 240.
The confusion is understandable, because that legislation did create New York’s first fault-based bar on recovery: a plaintiff more at fault than the defendant cannot recover. But that provision, CPLR § 1411(b), is limited by its own terms to personal injury actions subject to Insurance Law Article 51, which is the no-fault motor vehicle system. Construction accidents are not Article 51 actions. Pure comparative negligence continues to apply to § 241(6), § 200 and common-law claims arising on construction sites, and comparative negligence remains no defense at all to § 240(1).
Industry groups have argued that the new fault bar ought to reach § 240(1) by implication, and proposals to add a comparative fault overlay to the Scaffold Law have been introduced and defeated repeatedly over the past decade. Those are positions in a legislative debate, not current law. If that changes, this article will be updated. The firm’s post on New York’s 2026 motor vehicle reforms explains what the legislation did do.
9. Workers’ Compensation and the Third-Party Case
A worker hurt in a fall from height usually has two proceedings running at once.
Workers’ compensation pays medical treatment and wage replacement from the employer’s carrier, without regard to fault and without regard to the Labor Law. The § 240(1) case proceeds separately against the owner and general contractor, and is where compensation for pain and suffering and for losses the compensation system does not cover is recovered.
The two are connected at the end, because the compensation carrier holds a lien against the third-party recovery, and the amount it ultimately recoups is negotiable in ways most workers do not know. Filing for compensation does not waive the Labor Law claim, and accepting compensation benefits does not either. See workers’ compensation versus a third-party lawsuit and, for benefit amounts, New York workers’ compensation benefits in 2026.
10. What to Do After a Fall from Height
Get medical attention and say the injury happened at work. Head and spine injuries from falls are routinely worse than they first appear.
Report it to your employer and make sure a C-3 is filed. This starts the compensation claim and creates a contemporaneous record.
Photograph the equipment and the scene before anything is moved. Include the ladder or scaffold itself, its footing, the anchor points, and what was or was not available nearby.
Write down who was present. Include workers from other trades, because witnesses from other companies are the most valuable and the hardest to find later.
Note what you were given and what you asked for. Whether a harness had an anchor point, whether you asked for a scaffold, and who told you to use what.
Do not give a recorded statement to the owner’s or general contractor’s insurer before speaking to a lawyer. The questions are built to establish sole proximate cause.
Call a lawyer quickly. Site conditions change within days, equipment is reassigned, and the daily reports, safety meeting sign-in sheets and site photographs that decide these cases have to be demanded before they are routinely discarded.
11. How ARAVANA LAW Handles Scaffold Law Cases
Construction falls are among the most serious cases the firm handles and among the most evidence-dependent. Ara Naljian treats the first two weeks as decisive: preservation demands for the equipment, the daily reports, the safety meeting records and the site photographs; identification of every owner, general contractor and construction manager in the contractual chain; and a canvass for witnesses from other trades before the crews move on. Where the facts support it, the aim is partial summary judgment on liability, which puts the case in a different position entirely before any discussion of settlement.
The firm handles both the workers’ compensation claim and the third-party Labor Law case, which keeps the lien, the benefit rate and the lawsuit coordinated rather than working against each other. Clients work directly with the attorney from consultation through resolution, in Manhattan and Rochelle Park, New Jersey.
If you have been hurt in a fall or by a falling object on a New York job site, learn more about the firm’s construction accident practice or contact us for a free case review. Your own mistake does not defeat a Scaffold Law claim, whatever anyone on the site has told you.
This article provides general information about New York law as of its last reviewed date. Whether § 240(1) applies depends entirely on the facts of each case. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Consult a licensed attorney about your situation. Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
PERSONAL INJURY ATTORNEY
Get the Legal Help You Deserve
-
New York No-Fault Insurance and the Serious Injury Threshold: 2026 Update -
What to Do After a Car Accident in New York -
New York Notice of Claim Deadlines for Injuries Involving Municipalities -
How Long Do You Have to File a Personal Injury Lawsuit in New York? -
How Long Do You Have to File a Personal Injury Lawsuit in New Jersey?
Construction Accident in New York? Don't Let Important Evidence Disappear.
The equipment, safety records and witness accounts from a construction accident can be essential to understanding your legal options. ARAVANA LAW reviews the circumstances of construction injuries and helps workers understand the protections available under New York law.
- Free Consultation
- No Win, No Fee
- We Fight for You
It is Labor Law § 240(1), which requires owners, contractors and their agents to furnish and properly place safety devices — scaffolds, ladders, hoists, slings, braces, ropes and similar equipment — giving proper protection to workers on construction, demolition, repair, alteration, painting, cleaning and pointing work. When inadequate protection causes a gravity-related injury, the owner and contractor are liable regardless of their own care.
Yes. Section 240(1) is the only New York injury claim in which your own negligence does not reduce your recovery. In Blake, the Court of Appeals confirmed that comparative fault is impermissible under the statute and that once a violation and causation are shown, contributory negligence cannot defeat the claim. The separate question is whether your conduct was the sole cause, which is a different and much harder defense.
No. The statute lists scaffolds, hoists, stays, ladders, slings, hangers, blocks, pulleys, braces, irons and ropes, and then adds “other devices,” so the list is illustrative. What matters is whether proper protection against a gravity-related risk was provided. Ladder falls are the most common § 240(1) cases; falling objects, hoisting failures, missing railings and unbraced material all qualify.
No. In Runner v. New York Stock Exchange a worker was injured when an 800-pound reel being lowered down stairs with a rope instead of a hoist pulled him into a metal bar. He neither fell nor was struck by the reel, and the claim was good. The Court held the statute protects against harm flowing directly from the application of the force of gravity, not only from falls or impacts.
There is no minimum height in the statute. Courts look at whether the elevation differential was physically significant in relation to the forces involved, which depends on the weight of the object and the circumstances as much as the distance. A heavy object falling a short distance can qualify. Very small differentials with light objects often do not.