Does No-Fault Insurance Cover Motorcycle Riders in New York?

No, and the reason is a single definition in New York’s Insurance Law. That exclusion leaves motorcycle riders and passengers without no-fault benefits while also freeing them from the serious injury threshold when they sue an at-fault driver. Learn who pays your medical bills, which insurance coverages can protect you, and how the 2026 reforms affect your rights.

Does No-Fault Insurance Cover Motorcycle Riders in New York?

No. New York Insurance Law § 5102(f) defines “motor vehicle” for no-fault purposes to exclude motorcycles, and § 5103(a) excludes motorcycle occupants from first-party benefits. A rider or passenger injured in a New York motorcycle crash receives no no-fault benefits from the motorcycle policy or from the other driver’s policy. Because riders are not “covered persons,” the serious injury threshold does not apply to their lawsuit against an at-fault driver.

Key Facts at a Glance

  • No no-fault benefits: Motorcycle riders and passengers do not receive no-fault benefits from any policy (Insurance Law §§ 5102(f), 5103(a)).

  • Pedestrians struck by motorcycles: They do receive no-fault benefits from the motorcycle’s insurer under § 5103(f).

  • No serious injury threshold: Riders are not “covered persons,” so the serious injury threshold in § 5104(a) does not bar their pain-and-suffering claims.

  • Medical bills: These generally fall to health insurance, optional MedPay on the motorcycle policy, and ultimately the at-fault driver’s liability coverage.

  • SUM coverage: Supplementary uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage on the motorcycle policy can protect riders against uninsured and underinsured drivers.

  • Helmet requirements: Not wearing a helmet violates VTL § 381 and may reduce damages for head injuries, but does not automatically bar a claim.

  • 2026 fault rule: Whether New York’s 2026 fault bar under CPLR § 1411(b) applies to motorcycle riders remains unsettled.

Table of Contents

  1. The One Definition That Decides Everything

  2. What Riders and Passengers Lose: No First-Party Benefits

  3. What Riders Gain: No Serious Injury Threshold

  4. Who Pays the Medical Bills After a New York Motorcycle Crash

  5. MedPay and SUM: The Two Coverages Every Rider Should Check

  6. Edge Cases: Thrown From the Bike, Walking the Bike, E-Bikes and Mopeds

  7. How the 2026 Tort Reform Affects Motorcyclists

  8. Helmets, Comparative Fault and VTL § 381

  9. Coverage by Situation: Quick Reference Table

  10. What to Do After a Motorcycle Accident in New York

  11. How ARAVANA LAW Handles New York Motorcycle Cases

  12. Frequently Asked Questions

1. The One Definition That Decides Everything

New York’s no-fault system, Article 51 of the Insurance Law, requires every “motor vehicle” to carry first-party benefits coverage and pays those benefits to injured people regardless of fault.

The system turns on the definition of “motor vehicle” in Insurance Law § 5102(f), which incorporates the Vehicle and Traffic Law definition and then says that, for Article 51 purposes, a motor vehicle “shall not include a motorcycle.”

The exclusion dates from a 1977 amendment. The Legislature concluded that motorcycle injuries were severe enough and frequent enough that mandatory first-party coverage would make motorcycle insurance unaffordable.

Section 5103(a)(1) then requires every automobile policy to pay first-party benefits to persons injured by the use of the insured vehicle “other than occupants of another motor vehicle or a motorcycle.”

Section 5103(f) addresses motorcycle policies directly: they must provide first-party benefits to persons injured by the motorcycle “other than the occupants of such motorcycle.”

A pedestrian hit by a motorcycle is covered. The rider and passenger are not.

The result is a system in which the motorcyclist is in, but not of, no-fault: the rider’s own policy pays no-fault benefits to the people the motorcycle hits, and the rider receives none from anyone.

2. What Riders and Passengers Lose: No First-Party Benefits

A “covered person” in a New York car accident receives up to $50,000 in basic economic loss under § 5102(a): medical expenses, lost earnings of up to $2,000 a month for up to three years, and other reasonable expenses, paid within 30 days of a proper claim without regard to fault.

A motorcycle rider or passenger receives none of that.

In practice, this means:

  • Hospital and physician bills: These go to the rider’s health insurance, if any, and otherwise to the rider.

  • Lost wages: No insurer replaces lost wages while the liability claim is pending.

  • Medical billing: There is no no-fault arbitration or no-fault fee schedule; providers bill at their ordinary rates.

  • Liability claims: The at-fault driver’s insurer has no obligation to pay anything until liability is resolved, by settlement or verdict, which can take a year or more.

The passenger’s position is the same as the rider’s. Passengers often assume that because they were not driving, someone’s no-fault must cover them. Under § 5103(a)(1) and (f), it does not.

Image placement: Insert the medical-bills featured image immediately after this section.

 

3. What Riders Gain: No Serious Injury Threshold

The same exclusion that denies benefits also removes a barrier.

Insurance Law § 5104(a) provides that, in an action by a covered person against another covered person for injuries arising from the use of a motor vehicle, there is no right to recover non-economic loss except in the case of a serious injury.

A motorcyclist is not a “covered person” as defined in § 5102(j), because that definition turns on occupying or being struck by a “motor vehicle,” and a motorcycle is not one.

New York courts have therefore held that a motorcyclist suing a car driver does not have to prove a “serious injury” to recover pain and suffering.

A rider with a soft-tissue injury, a non-displaced fracture, or an injury that resolved in a few months can sue for non-economic damages that a car occupant with the same injury could not, particularly after the 2026 elimination of the 90/180-day category for covered persons.

The rider still has to prove the driver’s negligence and the extent of the injury, and comparative fault applies, but the threshold motion that disposes of so many car cases is not available against a rider.

4. Who Pays the Medical Bills After a New York Motorcycle Crash

After a motorcycle accident in New York, several different sources of insurance or recovery may be relevant. In order of practical priority:

  1. MedPay on the motorcycle policy. If purchased, medical payments coverage pays medical expenses regardless of fault, up to its policy limit, typically $5,000 to $25,000.

  2. The rider’s health insurance. Health insurance pays under its ordinary terms. Most plans assert a lien or reimbursement right against the injury recovery. Self-funded ERISA plans can enforce that right strictly, and Medicare and Medicaid have statutory recovery rights. Those liens are negotiated at the end of the case and are a significant part of what the rider ultimately keeps.

  3. The at-fault driver’s bodily injury liability coverage. This pays the rider’s full damages, economic and non-economic, once liability is established. New York’s minimum liability limit is $25,000 per person, which a serious motorcycle injury can exceed within days.

  4. SUM coverage on the motorcycle policy. Supplementary uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage steps in when the at-fault driver is uninsured, unidentified, or carries limits lower than the rider’s SUM limit.

  5. MVAIC. The Motor Vehicle Accident Indemnification Corporation provides limited recovery for qualified New York residents injured by uninsured or hit-and-run drivers when no other coverage applies.

  6. Workers’ compensation. This may apply if the rider was working at the time of the accident, such as a courier or delivery rider.

For a broader explanation of who pays after a motorcycle accident, including New Jersey’s PIP system, see our article, Motorcycle Accidents and No-Fault in New York and New Jersey.

5. MedPay and SUM: The Two Coverages Every Rider Should Check

Because no-fault will not help, two optional coverages on the motorcycle policy do the work that no-fault does for car occupants.

  • Medical Payments (MedPay). This is optional, inexpensive coverage that pays medical bills regardless of fault, with no lien in most policies, and pays immediately. Riders routinely decline it because they assume no-fault applies. Check the declarations page and consider adding it at renewal. $10,000 or more is worth considering.

  • Supplementary Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist (SUM). New York requires every auto and motorcycle policy to include uninsured motorist coverage at the minimum limits and allows SUM coverage up to the policy’s own liability limits. For a rider, SUM is protection against the common scenario of a serious injury caused by a driver with a $25,000 policy. SUM limits should match the rider’s liability limits; the premium difference may be small.

Both coverages are claims against the rider’s own insurer and carry policy conditions, including notice, cooperation and consent to settle for SUM. A SUM claim in particular requires the carrier’s written consent before the rider settles with the at-fault driver, or the SUM coverage can be forfeited.

If the accident involved an uninsured or hit-and-run driver, learn more about your potential recovery options in our guide to uninsured or hit-and-run driver accidents.

Image placement: Insert the motorcycle insurance declarations-page image immediately after this section.

6. Edge Cases: Thrown From the Bike, Walking the Bike, E-Bikes and Mopeds

The exclusion applies to “occupants” of a motorcycle, and the courts have had to decide who that includes.

  • Thrown from the motorcycle and then struck. In Boyson v. Kwasowsky (4th Dep’t 2015), a rider thrown from his motorcycle and then struck by the same motorcycle was held still to be an occupant of it, and therefore excluded.

    Whether a rider thrown from the bike and then struck by a different vehicle becomes a pedestrian entitled to that vehicle’s no-fault benefits has not been definitively resolved in New York. The sequence of impacts should be documented carefully for that reason.

  • Walking the motorcycle. A rider who has dismounted and is walking the bike is generally a pedestrian, not an occupant, and if struck by a car should be entitled to that car’s no-fault benefits. The facts, including whether the engine was on or off and whether the rider was astride or beside the bike, matter.

  • Passengers. Passengers are excluded as occupants, exactly like the rider.

  • E-bikes, e-scooters and mopeds. New York classifies these separately under the Vehicle and Traffic Law. Limited-use motorcycles (mopeds) are motorcycles for no-fault purposes and are excluded.

    Bicycles with electric assist and e-scooters are not motor vehicles at all, so a rider struck by a car is treated as a pedestrian or bicyclist and is entitled to the car’s no-fault benefits.

    Classification disputes are common, and the vehicle’s registration status is the starting point. Our forthcoming guide on bicycle and e-bike accidents in NYC will cover this subject in greater detail once published.

7. How the 2026 Tort Reform Affects Motorcyclists

New York’s FY2027 budget (Chapter 58 of the Laws of 2026, Part EE), effective for actions commenced on or after May 26, 2026, changed car accident litigation in four ways, explained in our article on New York’s 2026 motor vehicle reforms.

How each applies to a motorcyclist is a question the statute does not answer directly.

  • The 90/180-day category and fault-first sequencing. These are changes to the serious injury threshold in §§ 5102(d) and 5104(a). Because the threshold does not apply to a rider who is not a covered person, these changes should not affect a rider’s claim.

  • The 51 percent fault bar under CPLR § 1411(b). This provision applies, by its terms, to personal injury actions “subject to” Article 51. Whether a non-covered person’s action against a covered driver is “subject to” Article 51 is unsettled.

    One reading is that the bar reaches any action arising from the use of a motor vehicle in New York. Another is that it reaches only actions between covered persons, as § 5104(a) does.

    Until the appellate courts decide, a rider found more than 50 percent at fault should expect the defense to invoke the bar, and the rider’s lawyer to contest it.

    For riders, this makes fault evidence, including scene photographs, dash and helmet camera footage, and witness statements, as important as it has become for drivers.

  • The $100,000 cap under § 5104(d). This applies in “an action for a serious injury” by certain at-fault claimants, including uninsured, impaired and convicted claimants, or those involved in a felony and convicted. A rider operating without the required insurance who is partly at fault should assume the cap may be argued against them.

These provisions require careful legal analysis because the 2026 changes do not directly resolve every question involving non-covered motorcycle riders.

8. Helmets, Comparative Fault and VTL § 381

New York Vehicle and Traffic Law § 381 requires every motorcycle operator and passenger to wear an approved helmet.

A rider injured while not wearing one can still sue, but under New York’s comparative fault principles, the defense may argue that the failure to wear a helmet contributed to head or facial injuries. A jury may reduce damages for those injuries accordingly.

The helmet argument does not reduce damages for injuries a helmet would not have prevented, such as a leg fracture or shoulder injury, and the defense bears the burden of proving the causal connection with expert evidence.

Beyond helmets, comparative fault in motorcycle cases typically centers on speed, lane position, lane splitting (illegal in New York), and visibility.

Under CPLR § 1411(a), the rider’s share of fault reduces the award proportionally. Whether the 2026 § 1411(b) bar also applies is the open question discussed in Section 7.

Juror bias against riders is real and is addressed through jury selection and evidence, not ignored.

For additional information, read our article on helmet laws, rider bias and comparative fault in motorcycle claims.

9. Coverage by Situation: Quick Reference Table

The following table summarizes how New York no-fault coverage applies to different motorcycle-related situations.

SituationNo-fault benefits?From whom?Serious injury threshold applies to lawsuit?
Motorcycle rider struck by a carNoNoneNo (rider is not a covered person)
Motorcycle passenger injuredNoNoneNo
Pedestrian struck by a motorcycleYesMotorcycle’s insurer (§ 5103(f))Yes (pedestrian is a covered person)
Car occupant struck by a motorcycleYesCar’s own insurerYes
Rider thrown from bike, struck by the same bikeNoNone (Boyson)No
Rider thrown from bike, struck by a different carUnsettledPossibly the car’s insurerUnsettled
Rider dismounted and walking the bike, struck by a carGenerally yes (as a pedestrian)Car’s insurerYes
Moped (limited-use motorcycle) rider struck by a carNoNoneNo
E-bike or e-scooter rider struck by a carYes (as a bicyclist/pedestrian)Car’s insurerYes
Rider injured by an uninsured or hit-and-run driverNoSUM on motorcycle policy; MVAIC if noneNo

10. What to Do After a Motorcycle Accident in New York

The steps you take after a motorcycle accident can affect your medical coverage, insurance claims and ability to preserve evidence.

  1. Get medical care immediately. Tell your medical providers you were on a motorcycle. Billing generally goes to health insurance or MedPay, not no-fault.

  2. File a no-fault application (NF-2) within 30 days when appropriate. If there is any argument that you were a pedestrian at the moment of impact, such as being thrown and struck by another vehicle or walking the bike, submit a protective application to the other vehicle’s insurer. The deadline is short, and the cost of filing is nothing.

  3. Document the sequence of impacts. Record what hit you, in what order, and where you were when each impact occurred.

  4. Preserve camera footage. Save helmet-camera and dash-camera footage. Identify traffic and business cameras before their recordings are overwritten.

  5. Photograph the scene. Photograph the vehicles, road conditions, your riding gear and your helmet.

  6. Get witness names. Riders are often blamed reflexively, and independent witnesses can help correct an inaccurate account.

  7. Contact your motorcycle insurer. Report the crash and request your declarations page to confirm your MedPay and SUM limits.

  8. Avoid premature recorded statements and settlements. Do not give a recorded statement to the other driver’s insurer, and do not settle with the driver before your SUM carrier consents.

  9. Contact an attorney promptly. The three-year limitations period under CPLR § 214 is relatively long, but the 30-day no-fault application deadline, SUM notice conditions and evidence-retention windows are not.

11. How ARAVANA LAW Handles New York Motorcycle Cases

Motorcycle cases are built around three realities: no first-party benefits, a liability claim that is not subject to the serious injury threshold, and juror skepticism toward riders.

From the first call, Ara Naljian confirms every available coverage, including MedPay, SUM, health-plan coverage and MVAIC eligibility. He files protective no-fault applications where the facts support pedestrian status, preserves camera footage and vehicle data in the first week, and prepares the fault evidence the 2026 reforms have made decisive.

Health-plan liens are negotiated at the end so the rider keeps as much of the recovery as the law allows. Cases are prepared for trial from the start.

Clients work directly with the attorney from consultation through resolution, in Manhattan, New York, and Rochelle Park, New Jersey.

If you were hurt in a New York motorcycle crash, learn more about our motorcycle accident practice, our Manhattan office, or our Rochelle Park, New Jersey office.

For help understanding your situation, contact ARAVANA LAW for a free case review.

This article provides general information about New York law as of its last reviewed date. Several questions discussed, including the application of the 2026 reforms to motorcyclists, are unsettled. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Consult a licensed attorney about your situation.

Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Injured in a New York Motorcycle Accident? Know Your Legal Options.

Motorcycle accident claims involve different insurance rules, coverage exclusions and important legal deadlines. You deserve to understand what protection is available and what steps may help protect your claim. Speak directly with ARAVANA LAW about your accident and potential legal options.

No. Insurance Law § 5102(f) excludes motorcycles from the no-fault definition of "motor vehicle," and § 5103 excludes motorcycle occupants from first-party benefits. A rider or passenger injured in a New York motorcycle crash receives no no-fault benefits from the motorcycle policy, the other driver's policy, or any other source. Medical bills go to health insurance or optional MedPay, and the at-fault driver pays at the end.

 

In practical order: MedPay on your motorcycle policy if you bought it; your health insurance, which will usually assert a lien on your recovery; the at-fault driver's liability insurer once liability is resolved; your own SUM coverage if the driver is uninsured or underinsured; and MVAIC in limited hit-and-run or uninsured situations. Workers' compensation applies if you were working at the time.

No. The serious injury threshold in Insurance Law § 5104(a) applies only to actions between "covered persons," and a motorcyclist is not a covered person because a motorcycle is not a "motor vehicle" under § 5102(f). A rider can sue an at-fault driver for pain and suffering without meeting the threshold, though the rider must still prove negligence and the injury, and comparative fault applies.

No. Section 5103(a)(1) requires an auto policy to pay first-party benefits to people injured by the car "other than occupants of another motor vehicle or a motorcycle." The car driver's no-fault pays the car's own occupants and pedestrians it strikes, but not a motorcyclist or motorcycle passenger. The driver's liability coverage, not no-fault, is the source of your recovery.

No. Passengers are "occupants" of the motorcycle and are excluded exactly as the rider is, under § 5103(a)(1) and (f). A passenger's medical bills go to health insurance or MedPay, and the passenger's injury claim is against the at-fault driver (and potentially the motorcycle operator, if the operator was negligent), free of the serious injury threshold.

Scroll to Top