How Much Does a Personal Injury Lawyer Cost in New York and New Jersey?

Nothing up front, and nothing at all unless there is a recovery. What differs between New York and New Jersey is the ceiling the courts place on the attorney’s percentage and what comes out of your settlement before you receive your share. Understand the contingency fee rules, case expenses, and deductions before signing an agreement.

How Much Does a Personal Injury Lawyer Cost?

Personal injury lawyers in New York and New Jersey work on contingency: no fee up front, and no fee at all unless they recover money for you. In New York, the fee in most injury cases is one-third of the recovery. In New Jersey, Court Rule 1:21-7 caps the fee on a sliding scale starting at 33⅓% of the first $750,000. Case expenses are separate from the fee in both states.

Key Facts at a Glance

  • No hourly bills and no retainer check; the attorney’s fee comes out of the recovery.

  • New York: One-third is the standard ceiling in most injury cases, with a lower court-set scale for medical malpractice under Judiciary Law § 474-a.

  • New Jersey: 33⅓% on the first $750,000, then 30%, 25%, and 20% on each successive $750,000, under R. 1:21-7(c).

  • New Jersey caps the fee at 25% when the client is a minor or incapacitated and the case settles before trial.

  • Case expenses, including filing fees, medical records, and expert fees, are separate from the attorney’s fee and are deducted from the recovery.

  • Both states require written fee agreements, and New Jersey requires a signed closing statement showing exactly how the money was divided.

Table of Contents

  1. What “Contingency Fee” Actually Means

  2. The Consultation Is Free, and So Is Walking Away

  3. New York: The Fee Rules

  4. New Jersey: The Sliding Scale Under R. 1:21-7

  5. Side-by-Side: New York and New Jersey Fees

  6. Case Expenses Are Not the Fee

  7. What ARAVANA LAW Charges

  8. Liens: The Third Deduction Nobody Mentions

  9. A Worked Example

  10. Your Protections: Written Agreements, Closing Statements and Fee Disputes

  11. Questions to Ask Any Injury Lawyer Before You Sign

  12. How ARAVANA LAW Works With You

1. What "Contingency Fee" Actually Means

A contingency fee is a fee that is contingent on winning. The lawyer is paid a percentage of the money actually recovered for the client, and if there is no recovery, there is no attorney’s fee. There is no hourly rate, no monthly bill, and no retainer deposit to fund the work.

The arrangement exists because of who the clients are. Someone who has just been hurt, is out of work, and is facing medical bills cannot pay $500 an hour to litigate against an insurance company for two years. The contingency fee shifts that risk to the lawyer, who funds the case and is paid only out of the result. It is also why injury lawyers are selective: a firm that is paid only on recovery cannot take a case it does not believe in.

Both states regulate these fees closely because the arrangement puts the lawyer’s financial interest in the same pot as the client’s recovery. New York and New Jersey each cap the percentage, require the agreement in writing, and give the client a route to challenge a fee.

2. The Consultation Is Free, and So Is Walking Away

At ARAVANA LAW, the initial consultation for a New York or New Jersey personal injury matter is described as free and carries no obligation. You can explain what happened, hear whether there may be a case, and decide whether to proceed without paying for the initial conversation.

Nothing is owed unless and until you sign a written retainer agreement. Even after signing, a client may discharge the lawyer. What the discharged lawyer may be owed depends on the circumstances and is usually resolved out of any later recovery rather than billed directly to the client.

Before making a decision, ask for the written fee agreement and take the time to understand the percentage, expenses, and other financial terms.

3. New York: The Fee Rules

Most Injury Cases: One-Third

In New York, the contingency fee in most personal injury and wrongful death cases is one-third of the sum recovered.

The Appellate Division fee schedules give the attorney and client a choice between that flat one-third and a sliding scale:

  • 50% of the first $1,000 recovered.

  • 40% of the next $2,000.

  • 35% of the next $22,000.

  • 25% of anything above $25,000.

Because the sliding scale yields less than one-third on any recovery of real size, the one-third option is what virtually every modern retainer uses.

A percentage above the applicable schedules is treated as per se excessive and unreasonable.

The applicable Appellate Division rule citation must be confirmed for the Department in which the firm practices before publication. The exact section number should not be guessed.

Net or Gross: The Client’s Choice

New York requires the retainer to present two methods of computing the fee and to let the client choose.

The Net Method

Case expenses and disbursements are deducted from the recovery first. The attorney’s fee is then calculated as one-third of the remaining amount.

The Gross Method

The attorney’s fee is calculated as one-third of the full recovery before case expenses are deducted. This method is available only where the attorney agrees to be responsible for advancing the costs under Judiciary Law § 488(2)(d).

The agreement must explain both methods, show their financial consequences, and record the client’s election.

The net method leaves the client with more money on most cases. The comparison should be set out in actual dollars, not merely described in general terms.

Medical Malpractice Is Different

Medical, dental, and podiatric malpractice cases in New York are governed by Judiciary Law § 474-a, which imposes a lower sliding scale by statute.

Portion of the RecoveryMaximum Fee
First $250,00030%
Next $250,00025%
Next $500,00020%
Next $250,00015%
Over $1,250,00010%

The percentages are computed on the net sum recovered after deducting expenses and disbursements.

An attorney who believes in good faith that the schedule will not provide adequate compensation because of extraordinary circumstances may apply to the court by affidavit, on notice to the client and lienholders, for a larger reasonable fee.

These rules should be confirmed by the attorney before publication. The firm must also decide whether to retain this subsection as general legal information or remove it if medical malpractice is not a practice area it handles.

4. New Jersey: The Sliding Scale Under R. 1:21-7

New Jersey does not use a flat one-third contingency fee. Court Rule 1:21-7(c) sets a mandatory sliding scale for fees in tort claims.

Portion of the Net RecoveryMaximum Fee
First $750,00033⅓%
Next $750,00030%
Next $750,00025%
Next $750,00020%
Over $3,000,000Reasonable fee, on application to the court

The tiers were raised to $750,000 by an amendment effective September 1, 2014.

These percentages are maximums. A lawyer may charge less, and every contingent fee must still be reasonable under RPC 1.5(a).

Three New Jersey features matter to clients:

1. The Fee Is Computed on the Net Recovery

Under R. 1:21-7(d), case expenses are deducted before the percentage is applied, whether the lawyer or the client advanced them. Unlike New York, this is not a client election; it is the rule.

Post-judgment interest, liens, and hospital or medical claims are not deducted in making that computation.

2. Minors and Incapacitated Clients Are Capped at 25%

If the client was a minor or mentally incapacitated when the agreement was made and the case settles before trial begins, the fee may not exceed 25%.

Settlements for minors also require court approval at a friendly hearing under R. 4:44, where the judge reviews the settlement and the fee.

3. A Lawyer Who Thinks the Capped Fee Is Inadequate Must Ask a Judge

Under R. 1:21-7(f), the attorney may apply to the Assignment Judge, on written notice to the client, for a larger reasonable fee.

The client cannot simply be asked to agree to more than the permitted amount without the required court application.

5. Side-by-Side: New York and New Jersey Fees

FeatureNew YorkNew Jersey
Standard injury feeOne-third of the recovery, or the lower 50/40/35/25 scale by election33⅓% of first $750,000, then 30%, 25%, and 20% on each next $750,000
Source of the capAppellate Division fee schedulesCourt Rule 1:21-7(c)
Fee on very large recoveriesOne-third continues to apply under the described standard scheduleAbove $3,000,000, a reasonable fee set on application to the court
Net or gross calculationClient elects; gross only if attorney advances costs under Judiciary Law § 488(2)(d)Net, after deducting expenses under R. 1:21-7(d)
Minors and incapacitated clientsInfant claims subject to Judiciary Law § 474; court approval of settlement required25% cap if settled before trial; court approval at a R. 4:44 hearing
Medical malpracticeLower statutory scale under Judiciary Law § 474-a: 30/25/20/15/10Same R. 1:21-7 scale as other tort claims
Written agreementRequired under RPC 1.5(c), with letter of engagement under 22 NYCRR Part 1215Required and signed by attorney and client under R. 1:21-7(g)
Closing statementRequired in contingent fee matters, subject to applicable requirementsRequired signed statement after recovery under R. 1:21-7(g)
Fee dispute resolutionPart 137 fee arbitrationApplication to the Assignment Judge and fee arbitration committees

Contingency fee rules in New York and New Jersey as described in the November 2026 production package. These are maximums where applicable; actual fees are governed by the retainer agreement. Not legal advice.

6. Case Expenses Are Not the Fee

The single biggest source of confusion at settlement time is the difference between the attorney’s fee and the case expenses. They are two separate deductions.

Case expenses, also called disbursements or costs, are the out-of-pocket amounts spent to build and prosecute the case. They may include:

  • Court filing fees and process server fees.

  • Medical records, films, and narrative reports from treating providers.

  • Police and agency records.

  • Deposition transcripts and court reporters.

  • Expert witness fees, including accident reconstruction, engineering, life care planning, and economics. These are often the largest expenses in serious cases.

  • Investigators, photographs, surveys, and site inspections.

  • Trial exhibits, demonstratives, and jury consultants.

Who advances these expenses during the case, and whether the client is responsible for them if the case is lost, is one of the most important terms to read in any retainer agreement.

Practices differ from firm to firm. Both states permit a lawyer to advance costs with repayment contingent on the outcome.

In New Jersey, expenses come off the recovery before the percentage is calculated. In New York, the calculation depends on the client’s net-or-gross election described above.

Before signing, ask exactly what happens to expenses if there is no recovery. The phrase “no fee unless we win” addresses the attorney’s fee; it does not automatically answer the separate question of case expenses.

7. What ARAVANA LAW Charges

The exact fee arrangement depends on the written retainer agreement for the particular representation. Clients should receive the full terms in writing before signing and have the opportunity to understand how the fee and case expenses will be calculated.

At ARAVANA LAW, the fee information must explain:

  • The firm’s actual New York contingency percentage and whether it changes depending on the stage of the case.

  • The firm’s New Jersey arrangement within the limits of R. 1:21-7(c).

  • Whether the firm advances case expenses and whether a client must repay those expenses if there is no recovery.

  • How the New York net-versus-gross election is presented, including the dollar comparison.

  • Whether consultations are available in Spanish and by phone, video, and in person.

Ara Naljian handles client matters directly, from the first call through the closing statement, in Rochelle Park, New Jersey, and Manhattan.

Important publication requirement: The firm’s actual fee percentages, expense arrangements, and consultation formats must be inserted and approved by the attorney. This section must not be published with unconfirmed terms or placeholders.

8. Liens: The Third Deduction Nobody Mentions

After the attorney’s fee and case expenses, a third category may come out of the recovery: liens and reimbursement claims by organizations or providers that paid for medical care.

These may include:

  • Health insurance claims: Health insurers frequently assert a contractual right to be repaid from the recovery. Self-funded ERISA plans can enforce that right strictly.

  • Medicare and Medicaid: These programs have statutory recovery rights that must be resolved before the case closes. Ignoring them can create personal exposure for both the client and attorney.

  • Hospital liens: Hospitals can file liens for unpaid charges.

  • Workers’ compensation liens: Workers’ compensation carriers may have a lien on a third-party recovery, with their share reduced by their portion of the litigation costs.

  • No-fault and PIP reimbursement: No-fault and PIP carriers are treated differently in each state and may or may not have a right of reimbursement.

Negotiating these amounts down is real work and can make a meaningful difference to the client’s final recovery.

For example, a lien reduced by $40,000 puts $40,000 back into the client’s pocket. A detailed closing statement should show every lien, the amount negotiated, and what was ultimately paid.

The specific no-fault and PIP reimbursement statements must be checked against the applicable New York and New Jersey rules before publication.

9. A Worked Example

The arithmetic below is a simplified illustration of how the three deductions interact. It is not a prediction, an average, or a promise. It uses round numbers to show the structure only.

Assume a New Jersey case that settles for $300,000, with $20,000 in case expenses and a $30,000 health insurance lien negotiated down to $20,000.

  1. Settlement: $300,000.

  2. Less case expenses: $20,000, leaving a net recovery of $280,000.

  3. Attorney’s fee at 33⅓% of the net recovery: $93,333 under R. 1:21-7(d).

  4. Less the negotiated lien: $20,000.

  5. Amount to the client: $166,667.

In New York, on the same facts, the result depends on the net-or-gross election.

Under the net method, the fee would likewise be one-third of $280,000. Under the gross method, the fee would be one-third of $300,000, a difference of approximately $6,667.

That is why the New York retainer presents the two methods and their financial consequences in dollars.

Illustration only. Not an average or a predicted result. Actual deductions and outcomes depend on the facts, applicable law, and signed fee agreement.

10. Your Protections: Written Agreements, Closing Statements and Fee Disputes

Both New York and New Jersey have rules intended to protect clients entering contingency fee arrangements.

  • A written agreement before the work starts: Both states require a contingent fee agreement to be in writing and signed. New York also requires a letter of engagement under 22 NYCRR Part 1215. Read the percentage, expense terms, and scope of representation carefully.

  • A signed closing statement: New Jersey requires the attorney to give the client a signed closing statement after a recovery, itemizing the gross recovery, expenses, fee, and disbursements. Ask for a clear written accounting in New York as well.

  • Court review of the fee: In New Jersey, a client may ask a court to review the reasonableness of a fee. A lawyer seeking more than the applicable scale must apply to the Assignment Judge on notice to the client. In New York, fee disputes in many civil matters may be addressed through the Part 137 fee arbitration program.

  • Court approval for minors: A settlement for a minor must be approved by a judge in both states, and the judge reviews the attorney’s fee as part of that approval.

The exact application of these protections should be confirmed for the specific matter and jurisdiction.

11. Questions to Ask Any Injury Lawyer Before You Sign

Before signing a contingency fee agreement, make sure you understand how the lawyer will be paid and what expenses may be deducted.

Here are ten questions worth asking:

  1. What is your percentage, and does it change if the case goes to trial or on appeal?

  2. Is the fee calculated before or after case expenses come out?

  3. Do you advance the case expenses, and do I owe them if we lose?

  4. Who will actually handle my case day to day, and will I speak to the attorney or only to staff?

  5. Will you give me a written closing statement showing every deduction?

  6. How do you handle liens, and do you negotiate them down?

  7. What happens if I decide to change lawyers?

  8. For New Jersey: Is the fee within the R. 1:21-7 scale, and will you apply to the court for more?

  9. For New York: Which method of computing the fee am I electing, and what is the dollar difference?

  10. Can I have a copy of the agreement to read before I sign it?

A firm that answers these questions plainly and in writing gives you a clearer understanding of what to expect when the case ends.

12. How ARAVANA LAW Works With You

Every client receives the full fee terms in writing before signing, a plain-language walkthrough of what each deduction means, and a closing statement at the end showing where every dollar went.

Ara Naljian handles the case personally from consultation through resolution, negotiates liens rather than simply passing them through, and handles the property damage claim alongside the injury claim rather than referring it out.

If you were injured in New York or New Jersey, learn more about our personal injury practice or contact us for a free case review. There is no fee to talk and no obligation to hire.

This article provides general information about attorney fee rules in New York and New Jersey as of its last reviewed date. Fee rules and schedules change. It is not legal advice, does not create an attorney-client relationship, and does not state the terms of any particular representation; those appear only in a signed retainer agreement. Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Know What Your Case Could Involve Before Making a Decision.

A personal injury claim involves more than an attorney’s fee. Understand the contingency agreement, case expenses, and possible medical liens before deciding how to proceed. Speak directly with Ara Naljian, Esq., about your New York or New Jersey injury matter.

In most New York personal injury cases, the contingency fee is one-third of the recovery, and nothing is owed if there is no recovery. The Appellate Division fee schedules also permit a lower sliding scale, which the client may elect, and anything above those schedules is treated as excessive. Medical malpractice cases follow a lower statutory scale under Judiciary Law § 474-a.

New Jersey Court Rule 1:21-7(c) caps the fee at 33⅓% of the first $750,000 of the net recovery, 30% of the next $750,000, 25% of the next $750,000, and 20% of the next $750,000. Above $3,000,000, the attorney must apply to the court for a reasonable fee. These are maximums; a lawyer may charge less, and the fee must always be reasonable under RPC 1.5(a).

You owe no attorney's fee because the fee is contingent on recovery. Whether you owe the case expenses the firm advanced depends on your retainer agreement. Both states allow a lawyer to make repayment of advanced costs contingent on the outcome. Ask this question directly before signing and get the answer in writing. It is one of the most important questions clients should ask before hiring an injury lawyer.

You owe no attorney's fee because the fee is contingent on recovery. Whether you owe the case expenses the firm advanced depends on your retainer agreement. Both states allow a lawyer to make repayment of advanced costs contingent on the outcome. Ask this question directly before signing and get the answer in writing. It is one of the most important questions clients should ask before hiring an injury lawyer.

In New Jersey, the fee is calculated after expenses: R. 1:21-7(d) requires the fee to be computed on the net recovery, with case expenses deducted first. In New York, the client elects between the net method, where expenses are deducted first, and the gross method, where the fee is calculated on the full recovery. The gross method is available only where the attorney advances the costs. The retainer must explain both methods and show their dollar consequences.

Scroll to Top