Snow and Ice Falls in New Jersey: When Property Owners Are Liable
Is a Property Owner Liable for a Snow or Ice Fall in New Jersey?
The general statute of limitations for personal
In New Jersey, commercial property owners must take reasonable steps to clear snow and ice from their premises and abutting public sidewalks within a reasonable time after a storm ends; residential homeowners generally have no duty to clear the public sidewalk. Under the ongoing storm rule adopted in Pareja v. Princeton International Properties (2021), no duty arises while precipitation continues, unless unusual circumstances or a pre-existing hazard exist.
Key Facts at a Glance
Commercial owners: Have a duty to maintain abutting sidewalks and address snow and ice hazards within a reasonable time after a storm, subject to actual or constructive notice.
Residential owners: Generally have no common-law duty to clear the public sidewalk, even where a local ordinance requires it. They remain responsible for their own private walkways, steps and driveways and for making public sidewalks more dangerous.
Ongoing storm rule: Generally, no duty arises during an ongoing storm. The duty begins within a reasonable time after precipitation ends.
Exceptions: The owner’s conduct may increase the risk, or a hazard may have existed before the storm began.
Public sidewalks and lots: New Jersey Tort Claims Act immunities may apply, and a 90-day notice of claim is generally required.
Time limit: Private personal injury claims generally have a two-year filing deadline. Comparative fault can reduce or bar recovery at 51 percent or more.
injury claims in New Jersey is two years. This commonly applies to:
Car, truck, and motorcycle accidents
Pedestrian and bicycle accidents
Slip and fall injuries
Dog bites
Certain construction injuries
If a lawsuit is not filed before the applicable deadline, the defendant may seek dismissal of the case.
Table of Contents
The Commercial and Residential Divide
The Ongoing Storm Rule: No Duty Until the Storm Ends
The Two Exceptions: Unusual Circumstances and Pre-Existing Hazards
What “Reasonable” Looks Like After the Storm
Parking Lots, Walkways and Apartment Complexes
Local Snow Removal Ordinances: What They Do and Do Not Do
Snow Removal Contractors and Who Else May Be Liable
Falls on Public Property: The Tort Claims Act
Who Is Liable: Quick Reference Table
Proving a Snow and Ice Case
Deadlines and Comparative Fault
How ARAVANA LAW Handles New Jersey Snow and Ice Cases
1. The Commercial and Residential Divide
New Jersey draws a line that surprises people from other states. The common-law rule was that no landowner owed a duty to pedestrians on the public sidewalk. In Stewart v. 104 Wallace Street, Inc., 87 N.J. 146 (1981), the Supreme Court carved out commercial landowners, holding that they must maintain the abutting public sidewalk in reasonably good condition and are liable to pedestrians injured by their negligent failure to do so.
In Mirza v. Filmore Corp., 92 N.J. 390 (1983), the Court extended that duty expressly to the removal or reduction of the hazard of snow and ice, with liability attaching only if, after actual or constructive notice of the condition, the owner failed to act in a reasonably prudent manner.
Residential owners were left under the old rule. An owner-occupied home owes no common-law duty to clear the public sidewalk, and a homeowner who does nothing is generally not liable to a pedestrian who falls there.
The homeowner is liable for the private walkway, front steps and driveway on the property itself, and for affirmatively making the public sidewalk more dangerous. One example would be piling snow in a way that melts and refreezes across the sidewalk.
Whether a property is “commercial” is decided by its use and whether it is capable of generating income, not simply by zoning labels.
Stores, offices, restaurants, apartment buildings and investment properties are commercial. A multi-family house whose owner lives in one unit and rents the others has generated conflicting decisions and must be examined case by case.
2. The Ongoing Storm Rule: No Duty Until the Storm Ends
For decades, New Jersey trial courts split on whether a commercial property owner had to start clearing snow while it was still falling.
The Supreme Court resolved the issue in Pareja v. Princeton International Properties, 246 N.J. 546 (2021).
A commercial landowner has no duty to remove snow or ice while precipitation is continuing. The duty to take reasonable steps arises within a reasonable time after the storm ends.
The Court’s reasoning was practical: clearing during a storm is often futile and can itself be dangerous. Requiring property owners to maintain completely clear surfaces while precipitation continues would create a standard that may be impossible to meet.
The rule applies to the owner’s own premises, including parking lots and walkways, as well as abutting public sidewalks.
On July 30, 2026, the Court reaffirmed and applied the rule in a case arising from a 2015 fall in a Walmart parking lot in Union Township during a mixed snow, sleet and rain storm.
The plaintiff fell about two hours into the storm, after the owner’s contractor had salted the lot but with only a trace of accumulation on the ground.
A jury had awarded more than $1.3 million. The Supreme Court reversed and directed judgment for the owner, holding that ordinary remediation during a storm, such as salting with minimal accumulation, does not create the “unusual circumstances” that would trigger a duty before the storm ends, even where the plaintiff contends the salting made conditions worse.
This 2026 decision reinforces the importance of determining exactly when precipitation began and ended in a New Jersey snow and ice case.
3. The Two Exceptions: Unusual Circumstances and Pre-Existing Hazards
Pareja recognized two situations in which a duty can arise during a storm.
1. Unusual Circumstances Created by the Owner’s Own Conduct
A duty may arise where the owner’s actions increase the risk to pedestrians or invitees beyond the danger created by the storm itself.
After the 2026 decision, ordinary salting or plowing that turns out to be imperfect does not qualify. The plaintiff must show conduct that went beyond routine remediation and made the hazard worse.
2. A Pre-Existing Risk on the Property Before the Storm
A different exception applies where the hazard existed before precipitation began.
Examples include:
Ice or packed snow left from an earlier storm.
A known drainage problem that repeatedly creates ice.
An unrepaired property defect.
A dangerous condition that existed before the current weather event.
The storm does not erase an owner’s existing notice of an existing hazard.
The second exception is particularly important for injured people. Many New Jersey winter falls happen on ice that formed days earlier from a previous storm’s melting and refreezing, or from a downspout or grading problem that the owner has known about for years.
In those cases, the ongoing storm rule is not a defense because the hazard did not originate from the storm in progress.
4. What "Reasonable" Looks Like After the Storm
Once the storm ends, a commercial owner must act within a reasonable time and in a reasonable manner.
Neither requirement is defined by a fixed number of hours in the case law. Both are questions for a jury, based on the particular facts.
Factors courts and juries consider include:
How long after the end of precipitation the fall occurred.
The time of day and whether the business was open.
The amount and type of precipitation, such as a dusting versus a foot of wet snow, or freezing rain versus powder.
The size of the property and the resources of the owner.
Whether the owner had a snow removal contract and whether the contractor performed.
Whether the owner’s efforts were adequate, such as a properly cleared path rather than a token pass, and whether those efforts created new hazards such as refreeze.
Whether the owner had notice of the specific condition through complaints, prior falls or its own inspections.
Local ordinances requiring snow removal within a set period are often admitted as evidence of what is reasonable, though they do not themselves create civil liability.
For example, a business that opens its doors to customers several hours after a storm without clearing the approach may have difficulty arguing that it acted reasonably.
On the other hand, a business that cleared promptly but missed a patch of black ice may not be liable at all.
5. Parking Lots, Walkways and Apartment Complexes
The abutting sidewalk cases receive considerable attention, but many New Jersey snow and ice falls happen on the owner’s own premises.
These locations include:
Shopping center parking lots.
Storefront entrance walkways.
Office park paths.
Apartment complex common walkways.
Shared steps and parking areas.
In these situations, the owner is a premises possessor with the ordinary duty to keep the property reasonably safe for invitees and tenants. The commercial and residential sidewalk distinction does not apply.
A residential landlord owes tenants a duty to maintain common areas, including walkways and parking areas, in a reasonably safe condition. That duty includes snow and ice, subject to the ongoing storm rule.
Parking lots raise additional issues, including snow piled by plows that melts across the lot and refreezes, inadequate lighting, drainage problems, and whether the owner designated and cleared a safe pedestrian route.
Many winter fall cases involve a parking lot that was plowed but not salted, or salted once and never treated again after a thaw-and-freeze cycle.
6. Local Snow Removal Ordinances: What They Do and Do Not Do
Most New Jersey municipalities have an ordinance requiring owners and occupants to clear snow and ice from the abutting sidewalk within a set period, often 12 or 24 hours after the snow stops.
Bergen County towns including Rochelle Park, Paramus and Hackensack have such ordinances.
Violations are punishable by fines, and in some towns the municipality may clear the sidewalk and bill the owner.
However, these ordinances do not automatically create civil liability to an injured pedestrian.
The New Jersey Supreme Court has held that a sidewalk ordinance enacted for the public’s benefit does not by itself impose a tort duty on a residential owner who fails to comply.
For a commercial owner, who already owes a duty, an ordinance violation can be evidence of negligence.
For a residential owner, it generally is not a basis for liability to the pedestrian, although the owner may still be fined.
This is one of the most misunderstood points in New Jersey snow and ice law. It is also why many falls in front of private homes are not actionable against the homeowner.
7. Snow Removal Contractors and Who Else May Be Liable
A snow and ice fall may involve more than one potentially responsible party.
Snow Removal Contractors
A contractor hired to plow and salt owes a duty of care to people foreseeably on the property and can be liable for negligent performance.
Examples include:
Plowing without salting.
Leaving a parking lot untreated after a refreeze.
Piling snow where it will melt across a walkway.
The contract between the owner and contractor often contains indemnification and insurance provisions that determine, as between them, who pays.
The injured person may be able to sue both the property owner and the contractor.
Tenants and Managers
A commercial tenant that controls the premises and the snow removal, or a management company that assumed the duty, can be liable alongside the owner.
Adjacent Property Owners
Where runoff from one property creates ice on another, the source property’s owner may be liable.
Utilities and Others With Special Use
A party that installed or maintains something in the sidewalk, such as a grate, cellar door or utility pole, can be liable for hazards related to it.
Identifying every potentially responsible party, and obtaining the snow removal contract and the contractor’s service logs, is standard early work in these cases.
8. Falls on Public Property: The Tort Claims Act
When a fall occurs on a public sidewalk, municipal parking lot, school walkway or county building’s steps, the New Jersey Tort Claims Act controls, and the legal analysis changes.
Weather Immunity — N.J.S.A. 59:4-7
A public entity is not liable for an injury caused solely by the effect of weather conditions on the use of streets and highways.
Courts have confined this to roadways; it does not by its terms cover sidewalks and parking lots.
Snow Removal Immunity — Miehl v. Darpino
A common-law immunity, recognized in Miehl v. Darpino, 53 N.J. 49 (1968), and held to survive the Act, protects public entities from liability for injuries caused by their snow removal activities themselves.
One example is a snowbank created by plowing.
Dangerous Condition — N.J.S.A. 59:4-2
Outside those immunities, the injured person must prove:
A dangerous condition of public property.
The required notice.
That the entity’s action or inaction was “palpably unreasonable.”
This is a higher standard than ordinary negligence.
Resource allocation decisions, such as the order in which a town plows its streets, are generally protected.
Procedure and Deadlines
A notice of claim within 90 days is generally required.
The Act also imposes a higher threshold for pain and suffering claims.
Public-entity snow cases are difficult but not impossible. Facts that may defeat the immunities, such as a pre-existing drainage defect, a condition unrelated to plowing, or actual complaints that were ignored, must be investigated quickly.
For additional information, see the firm’s article on the New Jersey Tort Claims Act when that forthcoming post is published, as well as the firm’s guide:
How Long Do You Have to File a Personal Injury Lawsuit in New Jersey?
9. Who Is Liable: Quick Reference Table
| Where You Fell | Owner Type | Duty to Clear Snow and Ice? | Ongoing Storm Rule Applies? | Typical Defendants |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Public sidewalk in front of a store, office, restaurant or apartment building | Commercial | Yes, within a reasonable time after the storm | Yes | Owner, tenant in control, snow contractor |
| Public sidewalk in front of an owner-occupied home | Residential | No common-law duty; ordinance violation alone does not create liability | Not reached | Usually none, unless owner made it worse |
| Public sidewalk in front of a rented house or investment property | Commercial, fact-dependent | Generally yes | Yes | Owner |
| Store or office parking lot or walkway | Commercial | Yes, ordinary premises duty to invitees | Yes | Owner, contractor, manager |
| Apartment complex common walkway, steps or lot | Landlord | Yes, duty to tenants and guests | Yes | Landlord, management, contractor |
| Private walkway or steps of a single-family home | Residential premises | Yes, to invited guests, under reasonable care | Yes | Homeowner |
| Municipal sidewalk, lot or building | Public entity | Only if dangerous-condition requirements are met and conduct is palpably unreasonable; immunities apply | Immunities instead | Municipality, county, school board; 90-day notice |
Table caption: New Jersey snow and ice fall liability by location and owner type as of November 2026. Every case depends on its facts; not legal advice.
10. Proving a Snow and Ice Case
Snow and ice cases are won or lost on evidence that can disappear within hours.
The firm looks for several important categories of evidence.
1. Weather Data
Certified records from the nearest weather station, including Teterboro, Newark and Caldwell, help establish:
When precipitation started and stopped.
The type and amount of precipitation.
The temperature cycle in the days before the fall.
This information helps determine whether the ongoing storm rule applies and whether a refreeze hazard existed before the storm.
2. Photographs and Video
Photographs should document the surface at the time of the fall, with scale and context.
They should also show the surrounding parking lot or sidewalk and any snow piles, downspouts or drainage features that may have contributed to the ice.
3. The Owner’s Records
Relevant records may include:
Snow removal contracts.
Contractor service logs.
Salt purchase records.
Inspection logs.
Incident reports.
These records can be obtained through preservation letters and discovery.
4. Prior Complaints and Falls
Municipal complaints, tenant complaints and prior incident reports may establish that the owner knew about a recurring condition.
5. Surveillance Footage
Most commercial properties have cameras. Surveillance footage may be overwritten within days to weeks.
Preserving it promptly can be important to determining how the fall happened and what the property looked like beforehand.
6. Witnesses
Potential witnesses include the people who helped after the fall, the employee who completed the incident report, and the contractor’s driver.
7. Medical Records
Medical records documenting the mechanism of injury on the day of the fall can help connect the incident with the injuries reported.
11. Deadlines and Comparative Fault
New Jersey imposes important deadlines on personal injury claims involving snow and ice.
Private Property Owners
Generally, an injured person has two years from the date of the fall to file a lawsuit under N.J.S.A. 2A:14-2.
Public Entities
A notice of claim generally must be served within 90 days under N.J.S.A. 59:8-8. A lawsuit generally must be filed within two years.
Comparative Fault
New Jersey’s modified comparative negligence rule under N.J.S.A. 2A:15-5.1 reduces recovery by the injured person’s percentage of fault and bars recovery at 51 percent or more.
Defendants routinely argue that:
The ice was open and obvious.
The pedestrian chose a shortcut.
The pedestrian wore inappropriate footwear.
Those arguments must be evaluated against the same evidence used to prove the case: the condition of the surface, the lighting, the available routes, and what a reasonable person would have seen.
12. How ARAVANA LAW Handles New Jersey Snow and Ice Cases
From the first call, Ara Naljian establishes the property’s commercial or residential character, pulls the certified weather data to fix the storm’s timeline against the time of the fall, and sends preservation letters for surveillance footage, snow removal contracts and service logs before they are lost.
Where the fall is on a public sidewalk or lot, a notice of claim is served within 90 days while the immunity questions are investigated.
The firm handles these cases from Rochelle Park, a few miles from the Route 17 and Route 4 retail corridors where many of them happen.
Clients work directly with the attorney from consultation through resolution, in Rochelle Park, New Jersey and Manhattan.
New York City sidewalk falls follow different rules. See Fell on a New York City Sidewalk? Who Is Responsible.
If you were hurt in a fall on snow or ice in New Jersey, learn more about the firm’s premises liability practice or contact us for a free case review.
Legal Disclaimer
This article provides general information about New Jersey law as of its last reviewed date, including the New Jersey Supreme Court’s 2021 and 2026 ongoing-storm decisions. Liability for a snow or ice fall depends on the facts. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Consult a licensed attorney promptly about your situation.
Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
PERSONAL INJURY ATTORNEY
Get the Legal Help You Deserve
-
New York No-Fault Insurance and the Serious Injury Threshold: 2026 Update -
What to Do After a Car Accident in New York -
New York Notice of Claim Deadlines for Injuries Involving Municipalities -
How Long Do You Have to File a Personal Injury Lawsuit in New York? -
How Long Do You Have to File a Personal Injury Lawsuit in New Jersey?
Hurt in a Fall on Snow or Ice in New Jersey? The Timeline Decides the Case. Start Now.
Whether the storm had ended, whether the ice was there before it began, and whether the owner acted reasonably are questions answered by weather records, surveillance footage and service logs that disappear within days. ARAVANA LAW preserves that evidence immediately and knows the rules the New Jersey Supreme Court set in 2021 and 2026. You will work directly with Ara Naljian, Esq., from the first call to resolution.
- Free Consultation
- No Win, No Fee
- We Fight for You
It depends on the property and the timing. Commercial owners, including stores, offices, apartment buildings and rental properties, must take reasonable steps to clear snow and ice from their premises and abutting sidewalks within a reasonable time after a storm ends. They may be liable if they fail to act after notice of the condition. Owner-occupied homes generally owe no common-law duty to clear the public sidewalk. No duty generally arises while the storm is still in progress.
Usually not against the owner for the storm's own snow or ice. Under the ongoing storm rule from Pareja v. Princeton International Properties (2021), reaffirmed in July 2026, a commercial owner's duty begins a reasonable time after precipitation ends. Exceptions may apply where the owner's conduct created unusual circumstances that increased the risk, or where the hazard existed before the storm, such as ice from an earlier storm or a known drainage problem.
Generally no, as to the public sidewalk. New Jersey common law imposes no duty on an owner-occupied residence to clear the abutting public sidewalk. A town ordinance requiring removal, while enforceable by fine, does not by itself make the homeowner liable to a pedestrian. The homeowner remains responsible for the private walkway, steps and driveway and for affirmatively making the public sidewalk more dangerous.
A reasonable time after the storm ends. Courts have not established a fixed number of hours. Juries consider how long after precipitation stopped the fall occurred, whether the business was open, the amount and type of snow, the size of the property, and what the owner actually did. Local ordinances requiring removal within 12 or 24 hours are often admitted as evidence of what is reasonable.
The ongoing storm rule was adopted by the New Jersey Supreme Court in Pareja v. Princeton International Properties (2021). It generally provides that a commercial landowner has no duty to remove snow or ice while a storm is in progress. The duty arises within a reasonable time afterward. In July 2026, the Court reaffirmed the rule, holding that ordinary salting during a storm does not create the unusual circumstances that would trigger an earlier duty.